← Back to prospect
Print-ready scout sheet
Phidarian Mathis
DT · Alabama · age 24.0 · 6'4" · 310 lb
Draftanomics scout sheet
Board model
Generated August 6, 2026
Draftanomics pick
#125
Day 3
Bust probability
31%
Moderate
Actual NFL pick
#47
WAS
Consensus rank
#83
24 sources
Why this projection
+1.0 ≈ pushed pick ~25 spots earlier; −1.0 ≈ ~25 spots later
| Boards ranking him top-100 | +0.07 |
| Age at draft | -0.04 |
| High-school recruit grade | -0.04 |
| Year-over-year production growth | -0.03 |
| Pre-draft consensus | -0.01 |
| charting pass block grade | +0.01 |
| Athletic testing | -0.01 |
| charting coverage grade career avg | -0.01 |
Pre-draft consensus (25 sources)
ESPN Scouts Inc.#57
4 For 4 (Anthony Staggs)#59
Battle Red Blog (Matt Robinson)#92
Bleacher Report#39
Bleeding Green Nation (Ben Natan)#64
Blue Chip Scouting (Devin Jackson)#44
Blue Chip Scouting (Nick Price)#54
CBS (Chris Trapasso)#76
CBS (Josh Edwards)#67
Draftwire (Luke Easterling)#74
Fantasy Pros (Andrew Erickson)#69
Fox Sports (Rob Rang)#60
Nbc Sports (Thor Nystrom)#74
NFL Com (Daniel Jeremiah)#66
Ninety Nine Yards (Craig Strachan)#88
Pro Football Focus (Trevor Sikkema)#82
NFL outcomes (so far)
Seasons
4
Games played
0
Avg snap share
10%
2nd-deal AAV
$1.1M
Closest historical comps
| Player | Draft | Year 1 grade (of 20) | Arc |
|---|---|---|---|
| Neville Gallimore | 2020 · #82 | 4.6 | Contributor |
| DaVon Hamilton | 2020 · #73 | 4.5 | Starter |
| Larrell Murchison | 2020 · #174 | 1.4 | Backup |
| Robert Windsor | 2020 · #193 | 0.1 | Bust |
| Leki Fotu | 2020 · #114 | 2.8 | Contributor |