2018 class · 22 prospects

Defensive tackle DT

Sacks + TFLs + Senior Bowl. Athletic testing weighted higher for IDL than EDGE.

Likeliest career, by the outcome model.

How many defensive tackles land in each career bucket as the model's single most likely finish. This is a different question from the board grades below — a prospect can be a Day 3 grade and still have “starter” as his likeliest outcome. The tails (elite, bust) are where the model separates; the middle two buckets sit close to a coin flip.

Elite
1
Pro-Bowl-caliber career
Starter
11
Multi-year NFL starter
Role
4
Rotational / depth
Bust
6
Likeliest outcome is a bust
Likeliest career across the DT class
Elite
1
Starter
11
Role
4
Bust
6

The board.

All 22 defensive tackles with a draftable grade on Draftanomics's 2018 board, tier by tier.

Blue Chip1 player

Only Daron Payne carries a blue-chip grade at defensive tackle — the Alabama product projects No. 4 overall. Barely a seam here — Vita Vea comes off just 7 picks later. The model is planting a flag on Daron Payne, 13 spots ahead of where the room ranks him (No. 17).

4
Daron Payne
Alabama· 6'2" · 311 lb· consensus #17
A blue-chip grade with the room in agreement — consensus No. 17.
Blue Chip
bust risk 11%
1st Round2 players

The first-round tier is a pair: Vita Vea out of Washington at No. 11, with Maurice Hurst Jr. at No. 19 behind him. The drop behind Hurst is the story — Harrison Phillips does not come off the board for another 29 picks. And the floor is solid: the bust model, reliable for defensive tackles, clears everyone here.

11
Vita Vea
Washington· 6'4" · 347 lb· consensus #12
A first-round grade with the room in agreement — consensus No. 12.
1st Round
bust risk 10%
19
Maurice Hurst Jr.
Michigan· 6'2" · 292 lb· consensus #22
A first-round grade with the room in agreement — consensus No. 22.
1st Round
bust risk 6%
Day 27 players

The Day 2 tier runs 7 deep, opening with Harrison Phillips out of Stanford at No. 48 and closing with Tim Settle at No. 96. There is a real step down from there — Kahlil McKenzie sits 14 projected picks behind Settle. Taven Bryan is the tier's dissent — the room ranks him No. 25, our board waits until No. 75.

48
Harrison Phillips
Stanford· 6'4" · 307 lb· consensus #67
A Day 2 grade the room hasn't caught up to — consensus No. 67.
Day 2
bust risk 15%
73
Rasheem Green
USC· consensus #101
A Day 2 grade the room hasn't caught up to — consensus No. 101.
Day 2
bust risk 11%
75
Taven Bryan
Florida· 6'4" · 291 lb· consensus #25
A Day 2 grade, though the room is higher on him — consensus No. 25.
Day 2
bust risk 1%
80
Derrick Nnadi
Florida St.· 6'1" · 317 lb· consensus #123
A Day 2 grade the room hasn't caught up to — consensus No. 123.
Day 2
bust risk 31%
81
B.J. Hill
North Carolina St.· consensus #125
A Day 2 grade the room hasn't caught up to — consensus No. 125.
Day 2
bust risk 20%
87
Nathan Shepherd
Fort Hays St.· consensus #95
A Day 2 grade with the room in agreement — consensus No. 95.
Day 2
bust risk 16%
96
Tim Settle
Virginia Tech· 6'3" · 329 lb· consensus #121
A Day 2 grade the room hasn't caught up to — consensus No. 121.
Day 2
bust risk 18%
Day 312 players

Kahlil McKenzie leads a 12-deep Day 3 group — the meat of the DT board — starting at a projected No. 110 overall. One caution flag: the bust model — a group it reads well at defensive tackle — puts Joshua Frazier at 46 percent.